Salary Scenarios: The Hard Math
To understand the gap between the sales pitch and reality, we need to look at three distinct living scenarios. These numbers represent the gross annual income required to sustain these lifestyles without accumulating debt.
| Lifestyle |
Single Income |
Family Income (4) |
| Frugal |
$45,000 |
$65,000 |
| Moderate |
$65,000 |
$95,000 |
| Comfortable |
$85,000 |
$130,000 |
Frugal Analysis:
To live frugally in Nampa, a single person needs a minimum of $45,000. This is significantly higher than the "survival" income of $39,463. At this level, you are renting a 1-bedroom or shared 2-bedroom ($1,100 - $1,200), driving a paid-off older car, and cooking 90% of your meals. You have a strict budget. A family of four needs $65,000, which requires extreme discipline: a modest rental in an older neighborhood, one reliable car, and zero luxury spending. This is a paycheck-to-paycheck existence where a $500 car repair bill is a crisis.
Moderate Analysis:
The "Moderate" scenario is where most aspiring residents aim. For a single earner, that's $65,000. This allows for a decent 2-bedroom apartment ($1,655), a reliable car with a payment, and the ability to save a little while eating out occasionally. You can afford a gym membership and maybe a weekend trip to the mountains twice a year. For a family, $95,000 is the entry point for stability. This allows for a starter home purchase (likely a townhouse or older detached home), two cars, and daycare costs (which are brutal in Idaho, often $1,000+ a month). You are comfortable, but you are still watching the grocery bill and utility costs closely.
Comfortable Analysis:
To live truly comfortably—meaning you aren't stressed about bills, you can max out a 401(k), and you can afford vacations and dining out without guilt—you need $85,000 as a single person or $130,000 as a family. At this income, you can afford a median-priced home ($450,000+) with a manageable mortgage, likely securing a rate under 7% if you buy down points. You can handle the property tax bite and the insurance hikes. You have a buffer. Anything less than these "Comfortable" numbers, and you are just managing the decline of your purchasing power.