The Big Items
This is where your paycheck goes to die. The "big three"—housing, taxes, and daily consumables—eat up the vast majority of your income. In Columbus, the dynamics are specific.
Housing:
The housing market in Columbus is a tale of two distinct paths: renting and buying. Currently, the median home price sits at $260,871. This is the anchor. For a prospective buyer, this requires a significant down payment, likely upwards of $52,000 (assuming a standard 20% to avoid Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI)), and a monthly mortgage payment that could easily exceed $1,800 with current interest rates and property taxes factored in. Is buying a trap? Not necessarily a trap, but it is a commitment. The "starter home" market is thin; you're often pushed into buying more house than you need because inventory at the lower end is scarce. If you aren't planning to stay for at least 5-7 years, the closing costs and the front-loading of interest on the mortgage mean you'll likely lose money when you sell. Renting, conversely, offers flexibility, but the rental market is opaque here. While national sites list averages, the local reality for a decent 2-bedroom apartment or house often hovers between $950 and $1,200 per month. The "heat" in the rental market isn't aggressive bidding wars like in major metros, but rather a lack of quality stock. You pay a premium for updated units. The real trap is the property tax. We'll get to that, but it makes the "mortgage is cheaper than rent" argument a lot weaker than it looks on paper.
Taxes:
This is the silent killer that relocators from zero-tax states ignore. Nebraska is not a low-tax haven. Your take-home pay gets sliced immediately. Nebraska has a progressive income tax system. For a single earner making around $45,000, you're looking at a marginal rate of 6.6%. That is a significant chunk of change that never hits your bank account. However, the real gut punch is the property tax. Nebraska consistently ranks in the top tier of states for property tax burden. For that median home of $260,871, the annual property tax bill can easily reach $4,500 to $5,000 annually depending on the specific municipality and school district levies. That is roughly $400+ a month baked into a mortgage payment, or a direct hit if you're a landlord passing it down to a renter. There is no getting around it. While there are homestead exemptions, they are marginal. When you factor in sales tax (roughly 7% combined state and local), the government is taking a heavy cut at every turn. You don't feel the sting until you look at your net worth at the end of the year.
Groceries & Gas:
Columbus is a regional hub, which helps keep some costs in check, but don't expect miracles. The cost of a gallon of milk or a loaf of bread is generally in line with the Midwest, which is roughly 5-8% lower than the national average. However, "local variance" is a real factor here. If you shop exclusively at the major chains, you pay the premium price. You have to hunt for the sales at the local markets to get the real value. Gasoline prices fluctuate with the rest of the country, but because Columbus is somewhat removed from the major refining centers on the coasts, transport costs can occasionally add a few cents per gallon premium compared to the national average. A single earner commuting to work (let's say a 15-mile round trip daily) will spend roughly $80 to $100 a month on gas. While the COL index of 90.4 suggests savings, the grocery bill is deceptive. You might save on the base ingredients, but convenience foods and name-brand items are priced identically to the coasts. You get better bang for your buck buying in bulk at the warehouse club, but that requires upfront capital and storage space.