Salary Scenarios: What You Actually Need
To survive here without drowning in debt, you need to look at income scenarios that account for the reality of taxes and housing. The table below breaks down what you need to bring home to maintain a specific lifestyle, assuming the "Single Income" is for a household of two, and "Family Income" is for a household of four.
| Lifestyle |
Single Income (Annual) |
Family Income (Annual) |
Notes |
| Frugal |
$55,000 |
$85,000 |
Strict budgeting. Renting a 2BR, no car payments, cooking at home 90% of the time. |
| Moderate |
$85,000 |
$135,000 |
Owning a starter home, one newer car, dining out 2x/month, basic gym memberships. |
| Comfortable |
$120,000+ |
$185,000+ |
Upscale housing, two newer cars, private school/daycare, frequent dining, hobbies. |
Scenario Analysis
The Frugal Scenario ($55k Single / $85k Family): This is the "survival" mode. At $55,000, a single person can make it work, but only by renting the $1,280 2-bedroom (likely with a roommate or in an older complex) and driving a paid-off car. There is zero room for error here. If the water heater breaks or you have a medical copay, you are dipping into credit. For a family of four on $85,000, this is a struggle. You are likely relying on public schools exclusively (no tuition budget), shopping strictly at discount grocery outlets, and utilizing the abundant free parks for entertainment. This is hand-to-mouth living where the "low" COL index actually matters because you aren't buying assets.
The Moderate Scenario ($85k Single / $135k Family): This is the "keeping up" baseline. This income allows you to enter the housing market, likely with a townhome or a fixer-upper single family. You can afford a car payment on a reliable vehicle ($400/month). You can budget for a date night once or twice a month without panic. However, for a family on $135,000, childcare is the wildcard. If you have two kids in daycare, that can easily cost $2,000-$2,500 a month, effectively eating one entire salary. In this bracket, you feel "middle class" until you look at your retirement contributions, which likely need to be slashed to make the monthly budget work.
The Comfortable Scenario ($120k Single / $185k Family): This is where you actually start to enjoy South Jordan. At $120,000, a single earner can afford a median home of roughly $550,000 with a manageable mortgage, save for retirement, and absorb the costs of hobbies (skiing, mountain biking). For a family on $185,000, you can afford the "Utah Lifestyle"—the boat for Utah Lake, the ski passes, the extracurricular activities for the kids, and perhaps private schooling to bypass the overcrowded public system. Even here, you aren't "rich"; you are simply insulated from the immediate shocks of inflation. You have to keep earning to keep this lifestyle, and one income loss puts you immediately on the downward slide to the Moderate bracket.