Top Neighborhoods
Rexburg's "neighborhoods" are more like distinct micro-communities, and choosing the wrong one can turn your commute into a slog or leave you isolated. This guide cuts through the noise to match you with the right patch of Idaho soil.
Quick Compare: Top Neighborhoods in Rexburg
| Neighborhood | Vibe | Rent Range | Best For | Walk Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Downtown Historic | Walkable, Academic | $950-$1,300 | BYU-I Students, Young Faculty | ~70 |
| South Rexburg | Family-Centric, Quiet | $1,100-$1,500 | Young Families, Established Pros | ~45 |
| East Rexburg | Newer, Suburban | $1,200-$1,600 | Commuters, Growing Families | ~35 |
| North Rexburg | Budget, Industrial | $800-$1,100 | Students, Blue-Collar Workers | ~50 |
| Rexburg Bench | Rural, Spacious | $1,000-$1,400 | Homesteaders, Privacy Seekers | ~20 |
Downtown Historic
Overview: The heart of the city, centered around the BYU-I campus and the iconic Manhattan-esque Smith Park. You'll find older, well-kept homes and a handful of newer duplexes on streets like 2nd West and 3rd East.
The Numbers:
- 🏠 Rent: $950 - $1,300/mo (1BR) | $1,400 - $1,800/mo (2BR)
- 🏡 Buy: Median home $320k - $380k
- 🚗 Commute: 5 min to BYU-I | 8 min to Walmart/Target corridor
- 🚶 Walk Score: ~70 (Very Walkable)
Local Intel: Parking is a nightmare during the school year, especially around the campus edges. The best coffee spot is The Hub on 2nd North, but it's packed with students by 9 AM. If you need groceries, walking to Broulim's Fresh Foods is easy, but expect crowds on weekends.
Who Thrives Here: BYU-I faculty, graduate students, and anyone who wants to live without a car.
Pros & Cons:
- ✅ Walkable to everything: campus, the Rexburg Tabernacle, and downtown businesses
- ✅ Strong rental market with older, character-rich properties
- ❌ Noise from student housing and late-night foot traffic
- ❌ Older housing stock means drafty windows and quirky plumbing
Schools: Madison School District #321. Downtown is zoned for Rexburg Elementary (solid), Madison Middle, and Madison High (both well-regarded).
The Verdict: Move here if you want to be in the middle of the action and prioritize walkability. Avoid it if you need quiet, off-street parking and hate the 18-year-old neighbor energy.
South Rexburg
Overview: The quintessential family neighborhood, built mostly from the 1980s to early 2000s. Centered around the Portneuf Greenway trail system and Rexburg Aquatic Center. Streets like S 2nd East and S 4th East are lined with mature trees and sidewalks.
The Numbers:
- 🏠 Rent: $1,100 - $1,500/mo (1BR) | $1,600 - $2,000/mo (3BR house)
- 🏡 Buy: Median home $350k - $420k
- 🚗 Commute: 10 min to downtown | 15 min to Yellowstone Hwy (US-20)
- 🚶 Walk Score: ~45 (Car-Dependent, but bike-friendly)
Local Intel: The Portneuf Greenway is your secret weapon for biking or walking to downtown without dealing with traffic on 2nd South. The Rexburg Aquatic Center is the summer hub for families. Traffic bottlenecks on 2nd South during school drop-off/pick-up for Madison Middle.
Who Thrives Here: Families with kids in elementary or middle school, professionals who work at the hospital or in town.
Pros & Cons:
- ✅ Quiet, safe streets with heavy foot traffic from families
- ✅ Proximity to parks and the greenway is unmatched
- ❌ Zero walkability to restaurants or shops; you drive for everything
- ❌ Housing stock is aging; many homes need roof/HVAC updates soon
Schools: Zoned for Rexburg Elementary or Legacy Heights Elementary, both rated above average. Madison Middle is a short bike ride away for many.
The Verdict: Perfect for families who value safety and parks over nightlife. Commuters to Idaho Falls will find the 25-minute drive manageable, but you'll be in your car for every errand.
East Rexburg
Overview: The new-build corridor, stretching east from the core along Main Street and 2nd North. This is where you find planned subdivisions with HOAs, like those near Teton Peaks and the Rexburg Event Center.
The Numbers:
- 🏠 Rent: $1,200 - $1,600/mo (1BR) | $1,800 - $2,200/mo (3BR house)
- 🏡 Buy: Median home $380k - $450k
- 🚗 Commute: 12 min to downtown | 20 min to Idaho Falls
- 🚶 Walk Score: ~35 (Very Car-Dependent)
Local Intel: The Rexburg Event Center (host to concerts and the county fair) is the landmark here. You're also close to the BYU-Idaho Center and the new hospital. The trade-off: you're at the mercy of the Main Street/2nd North intersection, which gets clogged during commuter hours and BYU-I events. For coffee, locals hit Dunn's Bakery on Main Street for a quick bite.
Who Thrives Here: Commuters to Idaho Falls who want a newer home without paying Idaho Falls prices. Also great for families who want modern amenities like bigger kitchens and 3-car garages.
Pros & Cons:
- ✅ New construction means lower maintenance and better energy efficiency
- ✅ Easy access to US-20 for commuting out of town
- ❌ Strict HOA rules in many subdivisions (fence heights, landscaping)
- ❌ Traffic on Main Street is a headache during BYU-I move-in/move-out weekends
Schools: Zoned for Legacy Heights Elementary (newer facility), Madison Middle, and Madison High. All are highly rated.
The Verdict: Ideal for commuters and those who want a "suburban feel." Avoid if you hate HOA fees and want to walk to a local pub.
North Rexburg
Overview: The budget-friendly zone, dominated by student housing and older, working-class neighborhoods. Bordered by the Madison County Fairgrounds and Portneuf River. You'll find cheaper rentals on streets like N 1st East and N 3rd West.
The Numbers:
- 🏠 Rent: $800 - $1,100/mo (1BR) | $1,200 - $1,500/mo (2BR)
- 🏡 Buy: Median home $280k - $340k
- 🚗 Commute: 8 min to downtown | 12 min to BYU-I
- 🚶 Walk Score: ~50 (Somewhat Walkable)
Local Intel: This area is closest to the Madison County Fairgrounds, so expect noise and traffic during the fair and rodeo events. The Portneuf River runs nearby, offering some green space, but it's not developed for recreation. The Rexburg Softball Complex is a major draw for local leagues. Avoid the blocks immediately surrounding N 2nd East late at night; property crime is slightly higher here (bike thefts are common).
Who Thrives Here: Students on a tight budget, blue-collar workers with jobs in the industrial park, and anyone who prioritizes price over polish.
Pros & Cons:
- ✅ Lowest rental prices in the city proper
- ✅ Quick access to the industrial park and US-20
- ❌ Higher crime rates, especially property crime (lock your car, hide your bike)
- ❌ Older, less-maintained housing stock; some rentals are slummy
Schools: Zoned for Rexburg Elementary and Madison Middle. Schools are decent, but the area has higher student turnover.
The Verdict: Move here if you need to save money and don't mind rough edges. Avoid if you have kids and want a pristine, quiet neighborhood.
Rexburg Bench
Overview: The rural fringe, west of the main city limits along the "bench" overlooking the valley. This is acreage living: manufactured homes, small farms, and wide-open space. You're near the Rexburg Tabernacle and the Portneuf River for outdoor access.
The Numbers:
- 🏠 Rent: $1,000 - $1,400/mo (varies wildly) | N/A for most apartments
- 🏡 Buy: Median home $300k - $400k (land + house)
- 🚗 Commute: 15 min to downtown | 20 min to Idaho Falls
- 🚶 Walk Score: ~20 (Completely Car-Dependent)
Local Intel: You'll be sharing the road with deer and farm equipment. Water rights are a serious consideration here—verify before you buy. The Rexburg Tabernacle is a beautiful landmark, but it's a drive to get there. For any real shopping, you're heading to the east side.
Who Thrives Here: Retirees, people who work from home and want space, and those with a "homesteading" mindset.
Pros & Cons:
- ✅ Privacy and space that's impossible in town
- ✅ Lower property taxes outside city limits
- ❌ You are responsible for your own road maintenance and snow removal
- ❌ No city services (trash, water, sewer) means higher utility bills
Schools: Zoned for Rexburg Elementary and Madison Middle. Bus rides can be long.
The Verdict: Perfect for those seeking solitude and a workshop. Avoid if you need to be near schools, healthcare, or want a social life without driving.
Final Advice
For young professionals and BYU-I staff, Downtown Historic is the clear winner for its walkability and community feel, despite the student noise. For families, South Rexburg offers the best balance of safety, parks, and school quality. Commuters to Idaho Falls should prioritize East Rexburg for its easy highway access and modern homes. If you're on a tight budget, North Rexburg is your only real option inside city limits, but vet rentals carefully. One last tip: if you're moving in August, expect traffic chaos for a week—BYU-I's move-in is a town-wide event.