Sumter
Investment Analysis

Sumter, SC
Investor Report

Comprehensive real estate investment analysis with cap rates, rental yields, and risk assessment.

Share:
52
Investment Score
Strong Buy
Cap Rate (Est.)
2.5%
Gross Yield
4.2%
P/R Ratio
14.8x
YoY Growth
-0.7%
Median Home Price
$263,500
Average Rent (1BR)
$933/mo
Median Income
$53,071
Population
43,065

Investment Breakdown

56
Value Score
43
Growth Score
47
Safety Score
64
Afford Score

Sumter has a price-to-rent ratio of 14.8x, which indicates buying is significantly better than renting.

The estimated cap rate of 2.5% is below average, typical of appreciation-focused markets.

Year-over-year price growth of -0.7% suggests a cooling market.

Rental Cash Flow Analysis

Monthly Income

Gross Rent $933
Annual Gross $11,196

Est. Monthly Expenses

Property Tax (~1.5%) -$329
Insurance (~0.5%) -$110
Maintenance (~1%) -$220
Est. Net Cash Flow $274/mo

Price Forecast 2026โ€“2028

๐Ÿ”ฎ Sumter Price Forecast 2026โ€“2028

Based on 5-year Zillow ZHVI trend analysis ยท Statistical projection
๐Ÿ“ˆ Upward Trend
PROJECTEDNOW$207K2027$223Kโ–ฒ 7.4%2028$230Kโ–ฒ 11.1%20232024Now
$242K$186K
Current
$264K
2026
Projected
$223K
โ†‘ 7.4% by 2027
Projected
$230K
โ†‘ 11.1% by 2028
5yr CAGR:+4.4%
Confidence:High
Rยฒ:0.85
โ–ผ

For the Sumter housing market forecast through 2028, the outlook points toward a period of stabilization rather than dramatic shifts. The current median home price of $207,404 and a recent YoY price change of -1.1% suggest a cooling phase following the strong 5-year price change of 24.8%. This moderation is healthy for a market with a Risk Grade of A, indicating solid fundamentals. The 5-year CAGR of 4.5% provides a more realistic baseline for future appreciation than the recent slight dip. With a market temperature of 59/100, we are looking at a balanced market where buyers have more leverage than in recent years but sellers are not facing a crash. Key local factors, such as the stable presence of Shaw Air Force Base and ongoing efforts to diversify the local economy, should support housing demand and prevent significant price declines.

When evaluating will Sumter home prices drop, the data suggests a floor is likely in place. The price-to-rent ratio of 16.5x, which is below the national average of 18x, signals that buying remains relatively affordable compared to renting, supporting underlying demand. The Days on Market of 52 indicates properties are still moving at a reasonable pace, preventing a major inventory glut. For those considering Sumter real estate Sumter 2027, the affordability of the area, with a median rent of $933/mo, will continue to attract buyers priced out of larger metropolitan areas. However, broader economic factors like interest rates and inflation will play a crucial role. The "NEUTRAL" buy/rent verdict reflects this equilibrium: it's not a prime time for speculative flipping, but a sound environment for long-term homeownership.

The forecast for 2026-2028 hinges on this balance between affordability and economic headwinds. While the 5-year price range of $166,192 โ€“ $210,059 shows past volatility, the current stability suggests a tighter band ahead. We anticipate modest appreciation, potentially tracking closer to the historical CAGR, as the market digests recent gains. Sumter's unique position, anchored by military employment and regional connectivity, offers a buffer against severe downturns. Ultimately, the Sumter housing market forecast is for steady, single-digit growth, making it a market for patient residents rather than quick-profit investors. The key takeaway is that while rapid appreciation is unlikely, a significant price collapse appears equally improbable given the market's strong affordability metrics and low-risk profile.

Projected Cap Rate (2027)
3.1%
5yr CAGR
+4.4%

Job Market

Unemployment 3.2%
National avg: 3.7%
Job Growth (YoY) +2.8%

Healthcare

68
Score
Below Avg

Risk Factors

High Crime Area
Declining Prices

Market Activity

Source: Redfin ยท 2026-01-31
Sale-to-List 97.1%
Months Supply 5.3
Price Drops 34%
Gone in 2 Wks 24%

Market Position

Affordability Below Avg
Safety Higher Risk

ROI Projector Estimate your total return

Adjust the sliders to model different investment scenarios for Sumter.

Total ROI
-121%
on $52,700 invested
Annual ROI
NaN%
compounded
Total Return
-$63,817
appreciation + cashflow
Mo. Cash Flow
-$1,147
year 1 estimate
Equity Growth Over 5 Years
Y155kY257kY360kY462kY565k
Appreciation
$0
Cash Flow
-$63,817
Final Equity
$65,053

* Estimates based on 0.0% annual appreciation, 3% rent growth, 5% vacancy. Does not include closing costs, tax benefits, or capital gains tax. For illustrative purposes only.

Rental Investment Calculator Estimate your monthly cashflow

Rental Income Estimator

Pre-filled for Sumter

Property

Purchase Price$263,500
Monthly Rent$933
Down Payment20%

Financing

Interest Rate6.5%

Expenses

Property Tax1.2%
Insurance (Annual)$1,500
Maintenance Reserve1%
Vacancy Rate5%
Property Management0%
HOA (Monthly)$0
-$1,054
Monthly Cash Flow
-$12,650/ year
-24.0%
Cash-on-Cash
1.3%
Cap Rate

Monthly Breakdown

+ Rental Income$933
โˆ’ Mortgage (P&I)$1,332
โˆ’ Property Tax$264
โˆ’ Insurance$125
โˆ’ Maintenance$220
โˆ’ Vacancy Loss$47
= Net Cash Flow-$1,054

Investment Summary

Down Payment
$52,700
Loan Amount
$210,800
Total Monthly Expenses
$1,987
Gross Yield
4.2%

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investment decisions should be made after consulting with qualified professionals. Data sources include Zillow, Census Bureau, and BLS. Cap rates and yields are estimates based on available data.

Last updated: March 2026